And, like me, they are imperfect. They make mistakes. They have done things, sometimes, that were hurtful, or offensive, or inconsiderate . . .
and I have felt angry.
Now, I don’t mean the kind of anger that sustains us to work against deeply unjust situations–the anger that allows us, even in dangerous places, the courage to confront, the vision to imagine a world that is otherwise, and the space to heal.
I’m talking about anger as a drug.
Anger that says, first to me and then through me, that there is a price that must be paid for the pain that I feel. And which insists that in the meantime, the rest of our relationship must wait. In suspended animation. Until you do what you’re supposed to do.
Holding that anger made me tired. Waiting left me miserable. Imagine my relief, then, at the discovery that I could simply choose a different way of being.
At first, several months ago, that choice felt revolutionary. Now, though, it feels like freedom. It feels like friendship.
It feels like love.
Which sorta begs the question: why didn’t I try this before?
And friends, there are many reasons why I should have: because it’s morally right. Because to hold a grudge is to take poison and wait for your enemy to die. Because to forgive is divine. Because . . . Jesus.
And yet, in the heat of the moment, there seemed to be only one way that things could go: the angry way.
Why is it so hard to change things?
Perhaps part of the answer lies in scripting. This is one term for the social patterns that our brains and central nervous systems use to shorten our response time. Scripting is necessary–without it, each encounter would be a blank slate, and we would be slow to react and vulnerable to misunderstanding or manipulation. The device, however, is not without its pitfalls, and we often may not even realize we’re using it.
In some situations, in fact, the script may run counter to all of our conscious intentions. In this type of interaction, I’m not at all happy with the way we’re talking, and neither are you, but even so, we can’t seem to find a way out.
This difficulty can happen anywhere our sense of identity is on the line. The reality, however, is that some relationships are particularly ripe for unquestioned scripting. Consider, for example, the well-trod trails, heavily loaded with baggage, that connect mothers and daughters, or siblings, or spouses.
Sometimes the script is so old—we know our lines by rote—that we don’t even try to find another way to engage. Maybe it’s the only way we’ve ever learned to talk with one another. Maybe the interaction is feeding us even as it damages—meeting a need to feel important, to say our piece, to defend our boundaries. Maybe the hook is simply the adrenaline high of conflict.
Those same things are true of the script inside my head about How I Shall Act When Angry.
I have been deeply hooked into a particular way of being: Feel aggrieved. Demand response. Wait in anger until response received. Punish other party with dark thoughts and aloof behavior.
Has this worked well for me?
Not exactly. In fact, it reminds me of the scene in the first Harry Potter book in which Hermione announces that she hasn’t been speaking to Harry and Ron, and they respond, laughing: “Don’t stop now—it’s been doing us so much good!”
And so, a question decades in the making: what happens if I simply stop acting as a willing hostage to my anger?
Not because I’m restraining myself, or holding my tongue, or saving it for later—what if I do something else because on the whole, it feels better?
What if I do something else because I recognize, even in anger, that we are both human, and this is part of what that means?
What if I do something else simply because I can?
I am calling this the Happiness Option, and in practice, it can be summed up with one simple phrase: “In the Meantime, Be Nice.”
Truly, it felt odd at first. It’s like exercising an underused set of muscles.
It hasn’t, however, felt bad—not in the moment, and not later. Actually, it feels good to connect with joy, delightful to indulge my helping impulse, and freeing to step outside of the “angry” script.
And this immediate gratification is just the beginning. I’ve discovered that ditching the misery script also yields benefits for the long term:
I’m clearer about where I stand in my relationships.
I get to spend less time apologizing, less time feeling badly, and less time worrying about having caused further damage. (In fact, lately I have had to spend zero time doing any of the above. This is noteworthy.)
I am better situated to identify the problems that actually matter—which are a real slight to life and truth, and which—the vast majority—are merely a slight to my ego.
I have access to creativity and the sense of Spirit that comes in calm moments, and I can use both to choose when and how to respond to particularly thorny issues.
Indeed. This, my people, is news I can use. And so I keep flexing these muscles, and wondering if this practice—indignation back burner, niceness front—might just be pointing me to a deeper truth, and to a lastingly different way of being.
This might have remained merely a series of small experiments; I’m in no hurry here, and I have so. many. opportunities to practice. But, life being what it is, I recently got to take the Happiness Option for a test drive in a situation in which it mattered, bigtime.
Picture a sometimes challenging relationship, and not one I can simply break off. Imagine, now, an emotionally weighted subject. A sense of personal affront. An explicit questioning of motives. And the involvement, and invocation, of family ties.
Kindling on a pyre, my friends.
It was, in short, exactly the kind of conversation in which I hate to find myself.
In other words, perfect for this experiment. And predictably, that initial exchange did not go well.
Misunderstanding occurred. Tensions increased. Voices were raised. Reciprocal shaming was communicated.
The conversation ended without a clear resolution, and in a way that left neither of us feeling great. Afterward, my own combination of sadness, frustration, anxiety, and—yes—a healthy portion of righteous anger—begged to be vented. And yet, the Happiness Option suggested, at least for now, that I not.
Hard? Yes. It was.
But even so, I didn’t. I did not channel my anger into an e-mail missive. I didn’t plan a long communications strike. And, smaller but perhaps most noteworthy, I didn’t ignore the overture that my friend made the next day.
That gesture wasn’t an apology, an overt acknowledgment, or a plan to move forward. It did not, in many ways, Meet My Standards. But it was a hand extended toward remaining in conversation, even on this particular, very difficult issue—and after a moment to remind my muscles how to move, I reached out and I took it.
We are going to move forward, my friend and I. We will figure this out together, or individually, or we’ll ignore it and it will be an area where we do not share an understanding. I am now free, however, as the two of us move toward what the future holds.
In that freedom lies creativity, humility, and love. And happiness. Let us not forget happiness.
I took Hebrew Bible this spring at Meadville, and we looked at variations on the biblical canon. The Catholic canon is more expansive; the Evangelical canon a bit less. There are a few denominations, however, that hold that canon is still open. We Unitarian Universalists are among them, and I’m making a conscious choice to live like I believe it.
I’m not writing a love story to anger anymore. I’m writing one to you. To us. And to the sheer, luminous possibility, born of our own generosity, that this day yet contains.
Thank you, Theresa Soto, for this gorgeous meditation, shared here with permission:
In the Administrative Department of my heart, which is down the hall from Feelings, Major, I wrote down the time you offended me. The clerk, my own silent witness filled out the forms in triplicate. We wrote your name. We added your number. We added the hurt to the Memory Banks, photocopied, indexed (it can also be found in the Time Department, under Times You Forgot that I am able to be cut by paper and burned by wind). We shook our heads at the bitter sharpness of the hurt.
We made the Record of the Hurt. We announced it over the loudspeaker, so no cell, no heartbeat, and no breath would ever overlook the danger you present or the pain that you can bring. And then we were proud of our work. We stood quiet in the halls of Everything, hands in our pockets, and waited.
But Human still we both remain. And while we were Recording, in the most accurate, photorealistic way possible, you grew some more, and changed some more, and so did I, and believing the best yet to come, I was surprised to see that no recording of a single moment could reflect accurately on who you are right now. In this moment, different from the last. Some people say that Forgiveness, destruction of the Record, is for my own benefit.
Perhaps. But perhaps I don’t need you to apply to the Department of Sorry, (third floor, two doors down from Master List of Everything Unreasonably Kind) because mistakes are a human condition. There are too many forms and fines and details in the Administrative Apology. I want everything good for you. And for me. And this includes the way we just, as necessary for beings of our kind, begin again. Expungements and refreshments at noon in the Atrium.